** V.U. SONG CONTEST -- FINAL **

jimjim · Post by **jimjim** » 18 Mar 2005 10:33

Dammit....Sister Ray is great but Heroin changed the whole vast notion of songwriting i.e. tackling subjects that until that point novels & movies only did.

jimjim · Post by **jimjim** » 18 Mar 2005 10:34

Oh..I've just realised the poll isn't over yet....C'MON ALL YOU HEROIN LOVERS!!!!!!! VOTE VOTE VOTE!!

Saffie · Post by **Saffie** » 18 Mar 2005 17:01

jimjim wrote:Dammit....Sister Ray is great but Heroin changed the whole vast notion of songwriting i.e. tackling subjects that until that point novels & movies only did.

Exactly true! You said it so well...I would say that Heroin changed things lyrically, while Sister Ray changed things musically. That's why this is such a tough choice

Changeling · Post by **Changeling** » 18 Mar 2005 21:22

I agree with everything said about Heroin.
But when Sister Ray comes on I wish I had a spinal tap nob to turn
the stereo up to eleven.

I try not to analyse my vote too much.
I just vote for the song I'd rather listen to
if given the choice.

Sister Ray just holds a higher place in my soul.
It may be fun to revisit this poll in a year or two
and see if the collective tastes have changed any.
I know I sway between songs and albums with time.

If you fell a void because there are no more polls,
an idea for a another contest could be a poll on bootleg albums.

Thanks for all your work on the song contest arjan.
It was alot of fun.

Saffie · Post by **Saffie** » 18 Mar 2005 23:20

Another poll sure would be fun.

Really, yes, Thank You Arjan - this must have been one hell of a great amount of work for you!

sars · Post by **sars** » 19 Mar 2005 12:52

that was fun, changeling... let's do it again. you bring the kittens, I'll get the knife.

Changeling · Post by **Changeling** » 21 Mar 2005 19:10

sars wrote:that was fun, changeling... When I hear The Gift it just makes me purrrr...meow! let's do it again. you bring the kittens, I'll get the knife.

I picked up a doctor - she's good with a knife
Says anaesthetic's a waste of his time
Works in a hurry but always worthwhile
Knows they won't be back for a long long time

MJG196 · Post by **MJG196** » 07 Apr 2005 21:45

Hey Arjan, this was really cool of you...probably a bit time consuming as well. Should all good things come to an end though? HELL NO!

How about a poll of everyone's favorite UNRELEASED VU stuff?! Hey Mr. Rain, Countess From Hong Kong....stuff like that. Just an idea, bro!

tarbaby2 · Post by **tarbaby2** » 08 Apr 2005 00:23

if you're going along that train of thought... what about everybody's favorite version of Sister Ray? if i've counted right there's almost 20 different versions out there from various shows. that's one of the things i like so much about how they handled SR - each time they played it they made it sound almost completely different. it's as if we got a new song every time.

Homme Fatale · Post by **Homme Fatale** » 08 Apr 2005 13:58

mg196 wrote:UNRELEASED VU stuff... Hey Mr. Rain, Countess From Hong Kong

Both have been officially released... You mean non-album?

The Velvet Forum

V.U. SONG CONTEST -- FINAL

Sister Ray vs. Heroin