** V.U. Song Contest - First Round Match 8 **

arjan · Post by **arjan** » 26 Jan 2005 18:26

Match Eight of the First Round is between

Melody Laughter (off Peel Slowly and See)

and

I Love You (off Peel Slowly and See / Loaded (Fully Loaded))

For more information on The V.U. Song Contest, please see the sticky post at the top of this subforum; for yet more information and results so far, go visit Foggy Notion at http://home.hetnet.nl/~macplurkis/vu/index.html

iaredatsun · Post by **iaredatsun** » 27 Jan 2005 01:27

Maybe I'm being picky but can Melody Laughter really be called a song? Isn't it a piece of free improv? I wonder if it and things like Booker-T should be included.

cult · Post by **cult** » 27 Jan 2005 09:54

iaredatsun wrote:Maybe I'm being picky but can Melody Laughter really be called a song? Isn't it a piece of free improv? I wonder if it and things like Booker-T should be included.

It depends what do you consider under "song" , really...
I am very deep into free improvisation as a genre and i must say i am as confussed as you are.. does song has to have melody in it?
Well, this one has..in the name at least...

Chance · Post by **Chance** » 28 Jan 2005 01:44

Oh, I'm quite happy to see them included. I'd argue for their "songness."

Keepitwithmine · Post by **Keepitwithmine** » 01 Feb 2005 02:39

Booker T. isn't a free improvisation

Cameo Role · Post by **Cameo Role** » 01 Feb 2005 03:03

Melody Laughter isn't noise.

The Velvet Forum

V.U. Song Contest - First Round Match 8

Melody Laughter vs. I Love You

V.U. Song Contest - First Round Match 8